Casey Key is one of those rare islands that offer residents properties for sale that stretch from the Gulf of Mexico across Casey Key Road to Sarasota Bay. Owners of some of these Gulf to Bay Casey Key properties have magnificent yachts docked at their personal deep water dock and their own private beach. Beach cabanas are often an extra bit of the real estate provided to these Gulf to Bay property owners.
Casey Key Gulf to Bay properties, along with the entire luxury real estate market, are still in recovery. High-end property requests are coming into our sites for Casey Key real estate as buyers check out the lower prices on Florida west coast.
Casey Key is located south of Sarasota and north of Venice Floirda. One of Sarasota’s most beautiful barrier islands, Casey Key appeals to professionals and entertainers who enjoy their privacy. Stephen King is just one of the famous owners of Casey Key Gulf property.
Visitors, vacationers and buyers of luxury properties come to Casey Key year after year to explore the island and its pristine beaches. Seashells are abundant on this island along with sharks teeth and seaglass. Many buyers return Casey Key annually and take that opportunity to view property for sale in Paradise.
The Sarasota MLS currently reports a total of 53 single family homes for sale on Casey Key. Prices range from $699,000 to $12,000,000. According to the MLS, there are 10 Gulf to Bay properties currently on the market on Casey Key. Prices for these luxury Casey Key homes range from $2,475,000 to $12,000,000. There is quite an array of extras in many of these waterfront mansions: You can find homes offering boat docks, cabanas, tennis courts and swimming pools. Inventory of property is currently excellent for the luxury real estate buyer.
Casey Key Real Estate Activity
- Active Home Listings: 53
- Single Family Homes for Sale: Priced from $699,000 to $12,000,000
- Homes Under Contract: 1
- Sales Last Six Months Closed Transactions: 6
- Selling Prices Closed in Last Six Months: From $975,000-4,500,000
The Casey Key FL real estate market currently favors the buyer. Buyers are making offers and savvy sellers are negotiating. Many luxury home sellers have the financial ability to continue to hold their properties until the real estate market improves. There are some home owners however who for one reason or another are ready to work with realistic buyers.
For all of your Casey Key real estate needs, call the John Allen Team at 941-544-6467.
Related Article:
Casey Key Waterfront Homes for Sale

